Simple ‘Monster Brownies’ {shh…they’re from a box!}

posted by Andrea | 12/15/2010

Moving during the holidays is tough — especially for someone who loves to cook and bake as much as I do.

Usually, during the holiday season, I stuff my pantry with baking essentials and pack my fridge and freezer full of delicious holiday treats!

This year, however; I’ve been doing the opposite. I’m on a mission to empty our freezer and eliminate the bulk of our pantry in time for our big move NEXT WEEK!!

Things are going pretty well and I’ve been saving a TON on my grocery bill each week! I’ve also gotten pretty creative with some of the “concoctions” and recipes I’ve come up with — using ONLY the ingredients we have in the house.

And I must say, these Monster Brownies are my best concoction to date! Not only do they start with a boxed brownie mix, but you can mix and match whatever extra toppings you have in the house!!

I used Heath, marshmallows, caramel, and Hershey’s dark chocolate chunks {all from the back of my freezer!}


{Print this Recipe}

  • Boxed brownie mix for a 9 x 13″ pan
  • 1 – 2 c. chopped Heath Bar
  • 2 Dark Chocolate Hershey’s candy bars — chopped
  • 2 c. mini marshmallows
  • 15- 20 caramels
  • 2 T. milk or cream
  • OR — any extra baking ingredients you’re trying to get rid of!


  • Make the brownie mix as called for on the box {in a 9 x 13″ pan}
  • Bake the brownies as directed but pull them out of the oven 3-5 minutes early
  • Top with all toppings EXCEPT caramel
  • Put back into the oven for about 5 minutes or until marshmallows are “puffy”

Now, you could just eat them “as is” — I garuntee they will be delicious!

But for an extra bit of ooey-gooey-goodness, I’d recommend drizzling them with caramel 🙂

For the caramel:

  • Unwrap about 15-20 caramels and place in a small microwavable bowl
  • Pour 2 T. milk over the caramel
  • Microwave on high for several 30-second intervals — stirring between each interval {see pictures below}
  • Drizzle caramel over brownies and let sit until firm

Oh, and if you’re wondering why I call them “Monster Brownies”, it’s because they are similar to my Monster Cookie recipe where I just dump a bunch of delicious candies and other baking ingredients into the dough.

Hmmm…these sure don’t look like a boxed brownie mix to me!


And since you’ll probably have a bit of caramel left over, treat yourself to a delicious apple dipped in caramel…

…with a piece of Monster Brownie for “dessert”!!

Christmas is ONLY 10 days away! If you’re searching for a simple, delicious, gourmet-looking dessert to WOW your family this season, whip up a batch of these Monster Brownies — it should do the trick!


Filed under: Food

Leave a comment

1 comment

  1. Tweets that mention Simple ‘Monster Brownies’ {shh…they’re from a box!} « Simple Organized Living --


    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Marry Blake, Fisher Nuts. Fisher Nuts said: RT @livingorganized: New Post: Simple ‘Monster Brownies’ {shh…they’re from a box!} Yum! […]