Car Seat Safety: Advice from Allstate

posted by Andrea | 07/24/2014
Print pageEmail page


Over the last few years, I’ve gotten many questions about the car seats we’ve chosen for our kiddos — especially since some of the pictures I share are of them in their car seats. I’ve also gotten a decent number of questions about car seat safety — most of which I never felt qualified to answer 🙂

So when the people over at Allstate insurance recently contacted me and asked if I would be interested in writing a few blog posts about anything home or auto related, I knew exactly what I wanted to talk about — car seat safety!

Over the past month or so, I’ve been able to email back and forth with Allstate and ask them a ton of the car seat safety questions (including all those questions from readers). I learned a lot in the process and am excited to share some of my findings today!

Before I get started with the expert advice, I’d like to first share what type of car seats we use for our kiddos, the reasons why we chose those car seats, and our opinions about the different seats.

Our Infant Car Seat:

We have the Peg Perego Primo Viaggio SIP 30-30 infant car seat.


The main reason we opted for this infant car seat is because we had a couple friends who highly recommended it — AND I found an amazing deal on a Peg Perego single stroller via Craigslist. So since the car seat fit the stroller (and I loved the stroller), we figured it was a no-brainer.

I also loved the extra SIP (side impact protection) and the fact that this particular infant seat could accommodate an infant up to 30 pounds (which could potentially be helpful if Simon keeps chunking out like he is!) There are tons of awesome features I love about this car seat and I’m SO glad we opted for this seat.

The only somewhat negative thing about this seat is it does seem like it’s quite “tall” from the bottom of the base to the top of the car seat. This is not an issue for my vehicle, but it might be more difficult to get in and out of a smaller car.

And speaking of the base, we purchased 3 extra bases (all off Craigslist) so Dave and my sister can each have a base in their car — and then we have one extra base to loan out if a grandparent is taking Simon.

Our Convertible Car Seats:

We have 2 of the Britax Marathon 70-G3 Convertible Car Seats.


We received our first Britax free after a freak car accident when Nora was 6 months old. We loved the seat so much that we eventually started looking for another one for Dave’s car. We were fortunate to find one used (from a friend and not expired) that works wonderfully for the few times Nora rides in Dave’s car.

The main reason I chose this car seat is because when I asked around on Facebook, the overwhelming majority recommended a Britax convertible seat. I looked around on Amazon and decided on this one as it had one of the largest weight/height range — as well as several other features I was looking for.

Although we didn’t use it for Nora until she was a year old, this seat is apparently safe for even tiny infants (in the rear-facing position).

Nora loves her seat and so do I. It’s SUPER comfortable and easy to get her in and out of — she can actually climb up in it by herself and get the chest strap buckled on her own!

Our Extra Car Seats:

We purchased 2 of the Cosco 40RF car seats for our parents’ cars.

costco carseat

Since both Dave and my parents live only a few miles away, we decided to purchase a less-expensive Cosco car seat for each of them. This way, they can have a car seat if they want to go on an outing with Nora and we don’t have to hassle with moving seats around.

From what I’ve read and heard from friends, these car seats are actually really great for the price (we got ours for $40, with a coupon, from Meijer). So far, we’ve been very happy with them and Nora seems to like them as well.

As far as safety is concerned, I feel like the Cosco seats are excellent — the cheaper prices are simply because they don’t have all the “bells and whistles” or other convenient add-ons like our Britax car seat. I’m not sure if I would love the Cosco seat for our everyday car seat, but for the few times Nora sits in our parents’ vehicles, this car seat is fabulous.

OK, so these are the seats we currently use. Obviously, we’re not ready for booster seats yet, but when that time comes, I’m sure I’ll do an updated post with that information 🙂

Now, it’s time for Allstate’s answers to my car seat questions…


Is it safe to fasten an infant car seat with a seat belt instead of using a base?

We almost always use the base to secure the infant car seat in our vehicles, but there have been a few times when we need to travel in a different vehicle so instead, we secured the car seat with the seat belt (as directed on the car seat instructions). I always felt a little guilty every time we had to do this — like it wasn’t nearly as safe, but apparently, it is OK!

Here’s what I learned from Allstate…

It IS ok to use the seat belt to buckle the car seat in, BUT also use the tether system if possible. All child safety seats and vehicles manufactured after 2002 must be compatible with the LATCH system (Lower Anchors and Tethers for Children). Also, some cars manufactured between 1999 and 2002 also have the system.

How long should children be rear-facing? And why?

I feel like this has been a hot topic among parenting circles over the last 18 months or so. When Nora was born, the “rule” was 1 year rear-facing — but now I’ve been hearing 2 years (or even longer!) I was definitely anxious to hear what Allstate said regarding these questions.

Here’s what I learned…

Birth – 1 year: Rear-facing child car seat in the back seat of the car.

1 – 3 years: Rear-facing child car seat in the back seat until they outgrow the weight and height limit of the car seat. (Normally, when children are over 1 year old and weigh over 20 pounds, you can switch to a forward-facing seat.)

2 – 7 years old: Forward-facing child seat in the back seat until they reach the weight and height limits recommended by the manufacturer.

8 – 12 years old: Booster seat in the back seat until your child is big enough to use the car’s seat belt (80 pounds is currently the weight when a child can “graduate” from a booster).

Are expensive car seats always better?

You know me, I’m always looking for a deal! The only reason we have a couple more expensive car seats is because we either bought them from friends, got them for free, or found a REALLY good deal on Amazon (and used Amazon gift cards earned from Swagbucks). If it wasn’t for those deals, we most likely would have much less expensive car seats — and thankfully, based on the answers below, that wouldn’t have been bad!

Here’s what I learned…

We looked at a variety of sources including Consumer Reports, NHTSA safety ratings, and the Baby Bargains ratings to make our decision. We found that some cheaper brands actually held up better in comparison to the more expensive ones.

One expert personally used a cheaper car seat that had better ratings than a much more expensive model, so more expensive does not always mean better and safer.

Is it OK to buy used car seats if you have them inspected?

We have personally purchased used car seats — but we knew the previous owners and felt confident that the car seats were still in very good condition. I realize buying used isn’t for everyone, but in our situation, we did not feel like we were compromising the safety of our children in any way.

Here’s what I learned…

Try as best you can to buy a brand new (rear-facing or convertible) car seat — that way you won’t have to worry about whether or not it had been recalled for safety reasons. And also, you will get more use out of a brand new car seat since the car seats have expiration dates.

Is it OK to attach toys to a car seat? 

In the past, we have attached small toys to the handle bar of our infant car seat — but then I learned we weren’t supposed to do that. Now I just keep that toy in the diaper bag and attach it before and after the car ride so Simon can still play with the toys while we’re in the store or going for a walk.

Here’s what I learned…

NO this is not OK. The toys can become dislodged and turn into a projectile in an accident. Unfortunately, there is no way to safely attach toys to a car seat. Your best bet would be to give your child something soft she/he can just hold in her hand.

One rule of thumb is that a toy is not safe for the car if it hurts when you toss it at your head or your spouse’s head 🙂

What is the purpose of car seat expiration dates?

I’ll be honest; car seat expiration dates have ALWAYS bugged me. After all, if it’s not in an accident, how can something that simply sits in a car expire? I never really paid any attention to car seat expiration dates before — but after reading Allstate’s response (see below) I realized that there is actually a reason for the expiration dates.

If you’re wondering, car seats usually expire 6 years after they are manufactured, and you should be able to find the expiration date (or the manufactured date) somewhere on the car seat itself.

Here’s what I learned…

There are a few valid reasons why you need to stop using the car seat once it passes the expiration date:

1. Technology Improves and Standards Change. A good example of this is that back in 2002, car seats were not equipped with lower anchor and tethers for children. Now, however, they are a standard feature in nearly all car seats. Car seat expiration dates ensure that seats being used are current with updated technology.

2. Materials Wear Down. Car seats were not made to last forever. Over time, the seat base can develop hairline fractures which may shatter in a crash and belts can become slightly elastic after years of use.

3. They are Only Tested for a Certain Period. After a certain amount of time, manufacturers stop testing older seats. This means they cannot attest to how older seats will perform in an accident.

OK, so those are the questions I asked and the answers straight from Allstate! I know I learned a few things from my Q&A session with Allstate — and I hope you did too.

Obviously none of us would ever knowingly put our children in danger, but I was surprised by how many of these car seat “best practices” I wasn’t following (and a few rules I was breaking too!)

Do you have any other questions you’d like me to ask? Or any other car seat tips or advice you’d like to offer? Leave them in the comment section and I’ll pass them along to Allstate!

This post was written as part of the Allstate Influencer Program and sponsored by Allstate. All opinions are mine. As the nation’s largest publicly held insurance company, Allstate is dedicated not only to protecting what matters most—but to guiding people to live the Good Life, every day. For more helpful tips like this, visit the Allstate Good to Know community.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Filed under: Life


Leave a comment


  1. Nicole


    Another reason to adhere to expiration dates is the plastic becomes brittle over time–even without hairline fractures–and especially in hotter climates. I had an experience with a carpet cleaner that was stored in a hot garage (less than 5 years old!) literally crumble in my hands when I unscrewed the bottom to clean out the hair and fuzz that had collected.

    And be wary of cheap car seats–they tend to be made on assembly-line, high-volume plants with less attention to safety. The testing standard for car seats is a rather low threshold–30 or 35 miles/hour, I think. Many of the cheaper models shattered at just 5 miles an hour faster than the minimum safety standard. Britax seats hold up well. (Still looking for the article with the actual stats. Will post if I find it.)


  2. Jenni


    If you’re not supposed to buy the seat itself used, shouldn’t you also not buy the base used? I would think that the base would be equally prone to failure with age and/or after an accident because of the stress the tethers/seatbelt put on it.

    On another note, hubby was not thrilled when I informed him I would be testing toy safety on his head…


  3. Johanna


    In Sweden, the recommendation is that the child travels in a rear-facing chair until they’re 4 years old and/or weigh 50 pounds. Before that the child’s neck is unable to support the weight of their head in the event of a crash, risking breaking their neck. I can’t believe the recommendations aren’t the same all over the world. Check youtube for crash test videos, front facing and rear facing crashes. So scary, but incredibly important.


  4. Angela R


    Great post Andrea! I love that you wrote about this because it is so important. The point of the above gal about straps being pulled taught is also extremely important. A good rule of thumb is the pinch test–one shouldn’t be able to pinch the strap. I also thought I would mention to avoid confusion for your readers that the carseat brand you refer to is actually “Cosco” (no T). Just mentioning that so folks don’t go to Costco looking for their store brand.


    Andrea Reply:

    Oh yes — thanks Angela. I was going to go back and fix the “Cosco” typo last night but forgot. I just fixed it now 🙂


  5. Jane


    I know it varies from stat to state and everyone has their own personal preferences but according to Michigan State Police website for booster seats, the requirement is: “Children to be properly buckled in a car seat or booster seat until they are 8 years old or 4-feet-9-inches tall. Children must ride in a seat until they reach the age requirement or the height requirement, whichever comes first.”,4643,7-123-64773_22774-113709–,00.html

    I only mention this because our 8 1/2 year old has been out of his booster seat (using the car safety belts in the back seat) since he turned 8 and he is no where near 80 lbs. I’m wondering if I should put him back in the booster.


    Andrea Reply:

    Thanks Jane — and yes, different states have different requirements.
    About your son, I am not the expert, but I’d think he is fine — especially if he’s in the back seat. I know many 8 year olds who are not in any type of booster. Of course, do whatever you feel is the safest for him!


  6. Becky


    Another tip is that nothing should ever be added to the car seat that did not come with the car seat, including pads on the straps, the “blankets” that are inserted in the seat (they go under the baby and then zip up around the baby), etc. The covers that go over the top of the car seat are fine, as they are not actually interacting with any part of the seat that touches the baby. Also, definitely NO winter coats on your kids when they are in their car seats!


  7. Susie


    We took a car seat safety class when I was pregnant with Tyler. One of the most important things we learned there was to really make sure your kiddos are strapped in tight enough. The belts should be pulled so snugly that you can’t pinch the strap. (this is really hard to explain in writing!) I am a huge proponent for rear facing as long as possible. We learned that it’s really about spine development, which is why they advocate for rear facing until at least 2. Parents argue that they think their child will be uncomfortable with their legs squished up. But really, think about how bendy and flexible kids are! Another argument is that they think their legs will be broken if riding rear facing, but I would argue better that then spinal injuries. For those mamas in the GR area, I highly recommend the car seat safety class through Helen DeVos Children’s Hospital! They also have Carseat inspections set up multiple times throughout the month to help parents make sure they are using their car seats correctly.


    Andrea Reply:

    Cool — I didn’t even know they had car seat safety classes! Good to know!


  8. Kimberley


    Great info! Thanks for sharing this!!! With our little girl on the way here in about 3 months, this is all very helpful! We will be re-using my son’s infant car seat (but I will be purchasing a different car seat cover since his was more boy-ish) but he is only 4 and so we already know that it hasn’t expired and we know that we weren’t in any accidents with it!!! This decision will definitely help us save some money since the car seat cover we are getting will only be about $40 (with an awesome $50 off coupon).


  9. Rachel


    The biggest pet peeve I had related to car seat expiration is what to do with old car seats… just throw them away?!? only to sit in a landfill somewhere? Then I learned about the Safe Kids campaign here in Western Michigan where you can drop off your old car seats and they will disassemble and properly recycle them!


    Kari Reply:

    I was wondering the same thing. Thanks for the information. I will look into whether there is a program like that near me.