My New Mix ‘n Match Wardrobe

posted by Andrea | 09/8/2014

mix n match wardrobe

All I can say is… FINALLY!

I’ve been waiting for what seems like forever to share this post with you — but since I ordered many of my new clothing items online, I had to wait for the SLOW over-Labor-Day-holiday shipping to get the packages to my house.

Then, of course there were so many pictures to take — all of which were taken by Dave, via my iPhone, in about 2 hours, with children being shoveled around in strollers to keep them out of the way (seriously, I wish I had a picture of us taking these pictures!)

It was a crazy process, especially for someone like me who doesn’t necessarily love trying on clothes or getting my picture taken, but I am beyond thrilled with how this post turned out — not to mention how happy I am with my new clothes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

P.S. This post took me HOURS upon HOURS to put together so I’m really hoping it is inspirational and helpful to those of you trying to put together a mix ‘n match wardrobe!

Also, I realize the photography (and the model) are not top-notch, but I do think that the purpose of this post is clearly conveyed. For me, that’s more important than how great my hair looks!

First things first. Let’s talk about the stylist I worked with.

About a month ago, I had Jessica of come to my house to do a wardrobe analysis (UPDATE: apparently this website no longer works and I have not been able to get in contact with Jess since writing this post.)

I was totally fed up with my clothes and needed some motivation to lose my baby weight. So Jess said to contact her when I lost the weight and we could work together to update my wardrobe.


She charges $150 for the initial wardrobe analysis — which was a crucial step for me. She actually comes to your house and weeds through everything in your closet, asking you a bunch of questions to figure out your style and what clothes you love (read more about that in this post).

She never once made me feel bad about my unstylish clothing choices (or the fact that I had 7 of the exact same t-shirt just in different colors). In fact, she said we could actually work with many of the clothes in my closet and just add in a few updated pieces to change the entire look!

Those few hours spent with Jess in my bedroom closet were probably some of the most eye-opening, why-didn’t-I-think-of-that-before moments of my life (at least when it comes to clothes!)

After talking with her for one afternoon, I now think about clothing (and shopping for clothing) in a completely different way. I’m a much more confident shopper now that I actually know what to look for, what fits me, and what flatters me.

Side Note: I was apparently buying all my clothes WAY too big — like consistently 1 to 2 sizes too big! It’s amazing how much better clothes look when they actually fit 🙂

If you had told me I would ever be working with a stylist to update my wardrobe, I would have laughed in your face. But now that I actually did it, I wish I would have done it years ago — although I didn’t even know this service existed until earlier this year!

I would highly recommend this process for any of you who hate shopping, who feel “blah” in your current clothes, or who just don’t know how to update your look. If you can’t afford it, ask for it as a gift. It was SO worth it for me!

OK OK, Let’s Get to the Clothes!

new clothes

I told Jess that I was definitely a “jeans and t-shirt” kind of girl… and she said we could run with that. So since I already had a decent selection of pants and skirts, Jess’s primary goal was to find me a few cute t-shirts and some cute COMFY shoes to go with the pants I already had.

I didn’t think she could to it… but boy did she prove me wrong! She managed to create a super comfy, super low-maintenance wardrobe consisting almost entirely of jeans and cute t-shirts, using much of what I already had… so I hardly spent anything out of pocket!

It would be impossible to take pictures of all the different ways I could wear every item of clothing in my closet. However, I now have a mostly mix ‘n match jeans and t-shirt wardrobe that consists of lots of black, grey, white, cream, navy… and a few pops of color to brighten things up.

Below, I’m sharing a few ways I’ve been able to mix ‘m match. And since many of you have asked, I’ve listed out every item of clothing in my closet at the bottom of the post — you’re welcome 🙂

cream long sleeve T





navy scoop neck T

grey striped dress

What do you think? Did I do OK?

I just love how I can go from super casual yoga pants and a sweatshirt around the house to cute and “put together” with the same shirt! Not to mention so many of the items pictured above can mix and match with so many of the other pieces in my closet.

Obviously, all of these outfits are geared more towards Spring, Summer, and Fall — but it was hot and sunny the day we took these pictures and I just can’t bear the thought of dressing for winter yet!

Also, I do want to note that most of the items I purchased were via ThredUp and Twice (two used clothing sites I frequently shop). Tomorrow, I’ll be sharing how I managed to get several of my “new” clothing purchases absolutely free (and how you can do the same!)

Finally, since I’ve already been asked why I’m spending money on new clothes now, even though we are hoping to have more children at some point, I think it’s important to mention I DID keep that in mind when adding items to my wardrobe. I have many open cardigans that work well with maternity tanks, and many looser, ruched tops that should work well for the first and second trimesters, before the massive belly appears. 🙂

my new wardrobe

Now for that list of EVERY item of clothing I own:

I’m always asked, “how many of ______ do you have in your closet?” So I figured a quick listing would be in order — especially considering the nature of this post and the fact that I’ll be talking about clothes clutter ALL week long.


  • Jeans = 6 (two pairs are colored)
  • Khaki pants = 1
  • Capris = 3
  • Shorts = 3
  • Dress Pants = 2
  • Yoga Pants = 3
  • Leggings = 2
  • Sweatpants = 2
  • Athletic shorts = 2


  • Tanks = 9
  • Plain short-sleeve casual t’s = 7
  • Plain long-sleeve casual  t’s = 6
  • Stylish t’s = 15 (many of these were new purchases)
  • Light-weight sweaters = 8
  • Heavier sweaters = 4
  • Sweatshirts = 4
  • Cardigans = 8
  • Athletic t’s (long and short sleeve) = 15


  • Shorter skirts = 4
  • Maxi skirt = 1
  • Casual dresses = 3
  • Maxi dresses = 2
  • Formal”ish” dresses = 2


  • Flip Flops = 3
  • Casual Flats = 5
  • Tennis Shoes = 3
  • Wedges / Heals = 2
  • Boots = 3


  • Scarves = 6
  • Bags =4
  • Belts = 4
  • Various Necklaces

Obviously, I’m not hurting for clothing — however, my goal with this closet makeover has never been to purge my closet to an extreme minimalistic state. Rather, I was hoping to remove everything I didn’t wear and love and add in a few pieces to tie everything together.

I’ve been successful at that so far and am very pleased with how my closet looks and functions. I’m certain I will continue to purge and add in new pieces over the next months and years, but I’m off to a good start — thanks in large part to Jess!

So that’s everything… for today! 

I really hope you enjoyed today’s post and are excited to come back tomorrow for more “clothes clutter talk”. I have a lot of fun clothes-clutter posts planned the rest of the week (click here to eventually read them all in one spot).

Now that I’m finished working with Jess, I’ll direct all future wardrobe questions to my 2.5 year old fashionista (seriously, look at that pose!)

Filed under: LifeOrganizingHomeClothesPurgingResources

Leave a comment


  1. Restocking My Wardrobe with Twice


    […] had read about Andrea’s new wardrobe and then later that week, happened to see that when you liked the Twice Facebook page, you got 50% […]

  2. 5 Days to a Better Morning Challenge (Day 5) Offer -


    […] If you need some encouragement to simplify your wardrobe, I highly recommend watching this video on the 10-item wardrobe. I also love these Rules for a Minimalist Wardrobe and Andrea’s post on her Mix & Match Wardrobe. […]

  3. 5 Days to a Better Morning Challenge (Day 5) - Money Saving Mom®


    […] If you need some encouragement to simplify your wardrobe, I highly recommend watching this video on the 10-item wardrobe. I also love these Rules for a Minimalist Wardrobe and Andrea’s post on her Mix & Match Wardrobe. […]

  4. Kylie Ross


    Hi Andrea, thanks so much for going to all that effort! I really feel quite inspired by your amazing wardrobe set up! Can I ask where you bought the nifty looking shelf dividers – I could really do with some of those.
    By the way you look fit and well and your hair looks lovely – well done on your healthy choices and taking such good care of yourself!
    I originally found your site through the personal planner facebook page as I was considering whether I really “needed” a 2016 personal planner… after reading how you used your I think I do!
    Thanks Again
    Kylie Ross


  5. Kate


    I love all your outfits and you look amazing. I am trying to get rid of things in my closet I don’t wear and keep and add to the things I like. It’d hard bc I gained weight and am not happy with my waistline :).. it’s a work in progress.


    Andrea Reply:

    Thanks so much Kate!
    It’s always harder to feel great about mixing and matching when you’re also trying to lose weight (or adjust to a new weight). That’s why I waited until my post-baby weight had settled before trying to create this new wardrobe. I think it would be really hard to do if my weight was still fluctuating. Maybe give yourself a few more months before you try to change up your wardrobe. In the meantime, you can start purging everything you don’t love and maybe pick up one or 2 new pieces that make you feel great right now. Even if you lose the weight and they don’t fit later, it will still be nice to have a couple of new fresh pieces now!
    Good luck!


  6. Anne-Marie


    I enjoyed reading this! (I’ve held on to several different clothing sizes as I’ve gained and lost over the years. And I moved recently and realised that I am drowning in boxes and boxes of clothes!) I could never do a 37 item ‘capsule wardrobe’ but recently, I’ve been hitting the thrift stores to find inexpensive items that fit and flatter. Why wear something that doesn’t make you feel happy or confident? Life is too short right?

    And regarding that gorgeous little fashionista of yours? I have one too (4.5 years)! In order to save more money, I have been seriously thinking that there should be a checklist for thrifty folks to tell us what is a need for her closet & what is excessive. You need some ‘for fun only’ items but she should wear everything that she has before she outgrows it, right?

    I hope that you find Jessica!



  7. rachel


    will Jess drive to Traverse City for an appointment? That would be awesome. Maybe I can convince my friend to schedule one too and she’ll come up to re-vamp both of our closets! (her site is broken at the moment so I can’t read up on her services).


    Andrea Reply:

    I’m not sure Rachel. I know she has a couple younger kids so I don’t know how that would work out — but it can’t hurt to ask! Here is the email address I have for her ( ) It’s weird that her website is down right now. I guess I haven’t talked to her much in the past 6 months… but I’m assuming she is still running her business.


  8. mary


    I have looked for years to find a list of number of clothing that is livable, thank you.


    Andrea Reply:

    thanks Mary — glad you found this helpful


  9. Nicola


    Your post has been life changing for me. I realise that I could dress way better as a mom of a 1 year old and 3 year old. I have no idea what goes together and usually get dressed without too much thought for how I look, and then feel bad when I’m out with the kids.
    Thanks to your post, which I have read loads of time now, I have booked a stylist to come to my home tomorrow and am shipping the kids off to the grandparents. I would never have DREAMED of splurging on something like this before, we are very frugal, grow our own veg, get all the kids clothes as hand me downs etc. But you made me realise that it is important to feel good about how you look.
    I am excited and nervous about the appointment…


    Andrea Reply:

    wow… “Life changing”! That’s quite a compliment Nicola!
    I’m glad you’ve been able to get some helpful tips and suggestions from my post — and that you feel inspired to evaluate your own wardrobe too! Congrats on hiring the stylist. I totally agree that it sounds like a crazy splurge, but at the same time, the amount of help it offered me (for something I simply could not do myself) was SO worth it!
    Have fun!